Become a Critic or Submit a Song
Register Now
It only takes 60 seconds!

Already have an account?
Login Now
Today Soul Peace Guardian of Alertness Soul Peace
3.5 stars [1 Vote, 3.5 Stars]
Latest Chat8/29/2010 12:46:08 PM EST
Sputnikov: Chat Now!
Chat Now!
Latest Comment 4 hours ago
Guardian of Alertness
MiddleAgeMusic: Guitar part is very cool. I like the flow and melody of the chorus. Dropped down an octave, the cho...
Latest Backstage 2 hours ago
Man Man Man
MeatMachineII: i fretted a f# and a# instead of g and b and bent em up a half step. I don't know what a tuning peg ...

onestarcity

6 Tracks Reviewed
70 Comments Posted
Yays: 0  Boos: 0
Critic Score 2/10
Joined: 12/2/2008
Band: OneStarCity

Average Rating: 4 stars

Web Site: http://myspace.com/onestarcity 
more feedback please
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
ummmm....this doesn't do anything, go anywhere, or even start.
Marathon
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
this is freakin rad. Kinda toolish...kinda just sexy. Nice work guys.
Best Days ( resubmitted )
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
this is nice. Nothing super stands out, but nothing sounds bad either. It's like cotton candy. Doesn't really show off musical prowess, but it does show that you know how to write a catchy song, which is the hardest part anyway. I say feature just cause it sticks in my head, which shows you did something right. The vocals sometimes seem a little off, but nothing too drastic.
Amateur Gambler
onestarcity [3/3/2009 6:20:40 PM EST]
Score: +0
Hey guys, been on tour for a bit and haven't stopped in. Thanks for the feature and all the comments and stuff....as for this song...

This is my favorite one of yours so far man. The voice is (as usual), a little echoey for my taste....I'd love to hear what you've got a little more raw. But the vibe of the song and the drum part works. I could totally groove to this for a while. I like the part towards the end where it just kinda jams out. Nice work man.
please criticize me
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
If I were to want to light candles and slit my wrists in a warm bathtub, I'd do it to this song. I'd be so bored that I would want to die. However, I'm pretty happy for the most part, sooooooo....not really down with this.
Binaural Shift
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
this reminds me of some bands I used to listen to growing up. It doesn't quite get a feature from me, but I'm diggin' this. I think it might need a little more variety, and a hell of a lot more bass, but that might be my speakers. I want to hear more.
Lyin' Eyes
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
turns out getting beat up for being in band class was worth it...I like this. I'd want to hear more from you guys...especially something more upbeat. I vote feature for this
Unexpected Rain
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: -1
effort is there, but the voice is a bit annoying, and this is 2009. SS.
First Time Memory
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
Ummm...I can't tell the difference between any country songs. So I'll vote feature for this because it sounds exactly like the big guys. I might notice if it sucked really bad, but as far as I can tell, you wear your tight jeans well.
Taking Out Ryan
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
This is different, but it just sounds noisy to me. I appreciate the efforts you go to to bring something new to the table though. A little too disjointed for me.
Mr Wolf You Know What Time it is
onestarcity [1/30/2009 11:44:02 AM EST]
Score: +0
Oh, and nope, no reference to csi. We just like screwing around with animal titles. Whatever they end up being called, just about every song started out with some kind of animal reference in the title. I think they guys may have some sort of strange fetish. We are from canada after all...
onestarcity [1/30/2009 11:39:42 AM EST]
Score: +0
Thanks dude...and incidentally, I use vic firth 5As too! Thanks for the feedback guys...it's a fun live song
Broke Horny & Pissed
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
I think the vocals should be louder in the mix, but this is rad #@&%!. I Fn love these guys.
Not Too Late
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
The production is great, but the voice sounds off...really forced, and it doesn't really fit. Also, this would have been much better in 1974.
Into the Cave We Go
onestarcity [posted during evaluation]
Score: +0
I like the tones you have going on, but this is generally very bland. It's the same thing overandoverandover.