Become a Critic or Submit a Song
Register Now
It only takes 60 seconds!
Already have an account?
Login Now
Yesterday
Don't Eat The Snail
Rob Darby
[1 Vote, 4.5 Stars]
Latest Chat
8/29/2010 12:46:08 PM EST
Sputnikov
:
Chat Now!
Chat Now!
Latest Comment
1 hour ago
Don't Eat The Snail
MeatMachineII
:
yeah, it would be no easy feat. I don't know that a similarity to the iron butterfly part takes away...
Latest Backstage
10 hours ago
carrying your vision
Nanaho
:
I really enjoy this :)
RSS / Podcasts
12/21/2009
Holding Up The Wall
By
Grant Dawson
Weighted
Rating:
[9 Votes, 4.34 Stars]
Views:
715
Link to this Song
Send to a Friend
Download MP3
Pop-Up Player
Featured Review
Ruud Slingerland
[12/21/2009 6:02:47 AM EST]
Score:
+10
Rated
Very skillful, would have been more to my personal flavor if it were a little bit more raw, especially the arrangement is (too) smooth.
Comments
Pynner
[12/26/2009 4:21:32 AM EST]
Score:
+0
Rated
FilipinoJEW33
[12/23/2009 5:39:20 AM EST]
Score:
+0
Rated
i'm really glad this got the feature. Sounds even better on repeated plays.
yunquekabal
[12/23/2009 3:26:50 AM EST]
Score:
+0
Rated
last line is stellar
dvernon
[12/22/2009 4:25:26 AM EST]
Score:
+0
Rated
Lively and live sounding recording. Doesn't sound like something you'd hear on the radio today but it would be great as a concert addition. As a fellow vocal/ piano songwriter guy I appreciate what your doing Keep it up.
ian wejchert
[12/22/2009 12:17:24 AM EST]
Score:
+0
you are the piano man?
unklespaz
[12/21/2009 10:11:27 PM EST]
Score:
+0
I'm guessing that Randy has done alright for himself
paulmars
[12/21/2009 8:05:19 PM EST]
Score:
+6
What's wrong with Randy Newman, anyway?
unklespaz
[12/21/2009 8:00:05 PM EST]
Score:
+1
I'd say it's a blusier version of Randy's style if I may be too bold on that
actually, vocally I wouldn't change a thing and while I find QC's comment funny I disagree with that statement- pretty professional, contemporary, or cool
neato!
qualcomm
[12/21/2009 2:16:22 PM EST]
Score:
+0
these lyrics need to be taken out and #@&%!d.
mdochniak
[12/21/2009 1:41:13 PM EST]
Score:
+0
Feel good music. Great vocal work. Very nice sound.
paulmars
[12/21/2009 1:17:33 PM EST]
Score:
+0
Rated
Maybe the vocals are fine, just play with some effects maybe.
Very skillful, master of your craft.
Below Ground Level
[12/21/2009 11:23:11 AM EST]
Score:
+0
Rated
Little too Randy Newman for my taste... very tight though.
G_Dawson
(song submitter)
[12/21/2009 11:01:21 AM EST]
Score:
+0
Thanks for all of the kind comments. I guess I'll take a consensus of "too smooth". I can understand, stylistically, where you're coming from... but I'm always trying to tighten things up. Maybe it's my insecurity! In any event, this song, and others, are available on iTunes. Just search my name and you'll find the album. Cheers.
derailleur
[12/21/2009 9:38:01 AM EST]
Score:
+0
Rated
smooth as silk! rad jam, the only thing that gets borderline smooth for me is the guitar/mandoline at the end. Otherwise, vocals and piano really stand out to me.
Richie Isaacs
[12/21/2009 5:42:08 AM EST]
Score:
+0
Rated
I love this.
Nuff said (below)
Richie Isaacs
[posted during evaluation]
Score:
+0
Cool, another upload from ya, good to hear some actual piano blues on here, would rather hear the piano than the accompanying guitar...nice work, vocals are fine, a little bit of Dr John grit wouldn't go astray but it's sweet as it is.
Ruud Slingerland
[posted during evaluation]
Score:
+0
This is great, I like this kind of Dr.John piano bar vibe
derailleur
[posted during evaluation]
Score:
+0
excellent job, great songwriting!
apache
[posted during evaluation]
Score:
+0
this would be my favorite billy joel song, if billy joel released it. and it would probably be a huge hit in that scenario too. voice is good, lyrics are good, recording sounds good. might not be the type of thing i typically listen to, but theres no way i could not feature it.
paulmars
[posted during evaluation]
Score:
+0
Very smooth. I'd take another swing at the vocal, with a little more verve and funk, seems a little too concerned with articulation or something right now and needs more abandon maybe. But certainly feature material.
yunquekabal
[posted during evaluation]
Score:
+0
really really good lyrics, and great energy. music about music is hard to put together without being cliche, and you do just the opposite of that. well done
FilipinoJEW33
[posted during evaluation]
Score:
+0
yeah great song. Alotta great stuff. I agree with paul on the vocals though. Its easy to sound bland when people sing songs about music (you don't really though). Some slang and scratches would accentuate the nice vibe you have though. Great chord progression and nice job mixing in all the instruments.
Critics who liked this also liked:
1.
Flood Water in the Farmers' Field
(105.8 points)
2.
Heard it on the Radio
(101 points)
3.
time
(85.3 points)